I have been ghosted in a hiring process. It happened as far back as 2019, before most of us had a name for it, and before anyone talked about fake job postings. Maybe it was always happening and we just did not notice. Either way, ghosting candidates has gone from rare to routine, and the companies doing it are paying a price they may not see.Ā
How Hiring Used to Work
I remember when applying for a job meant buying the Sunday newspaper and circling the want ads that matched your experience. You printed a cover letter on linen resume paper, sealed everything in a carefully addressed envelope, and sent it to the hiring manager by name. Then you heard back. A phone call or a letter invited you to the office for an interview.Ā
My first three jobs out of college, I was hired on the spot. One of them happened because a recruiter called the company and told them they needed to get me in the door. What a confidence rush. Someone looked at me, saw what I could do, and made a decision.Ā
What ATS and AI Screening Miss
Today, many companies rely on applicant tracking systems (ATS) and AI to screen candidates. Don’t get me wrong, AI is great for plenty of things. What it cannot do is see what a person is capable of.Ā
When I worked in HR, I read every resume. Whether 10 people applied or 210, that was the job: finding top talent. Me, not a machine. I looked for character and credentials between the lines, and for the people who had put in the work to make a difference. An ATS mostly checks whether the right keywords are on the page.Ā
Here is what that looks like in real life. I once recommended a candidate transitioning into cybersecurity with less than 2 years of experience required for the position. When I spoke with him, his desire to learn outweighed everything ‘missing’ from his resume. He grew with the company and became an integral part of the team. A keyword filter would almost certainly have rejected him, and the company would never have known what it missed.Ā
When Your First Interview is With No One
There is another layer I should mention: the AI interview used as a pre-screen. I have done one. You sit in front of a screen, answer recorded or automated questions, and talk to no one. There is no nod, no follow-up question, and no chance to ask what the role is really like. You also do not know whether a person will ever see your answers.Ā
Tools like this can save a small team time, and I understand the appeal. But when the first conversation a candidate has with your company is with a machine, it tells them something about how you value their time. Even a 15-minute conversation with a real person shows you what a resume and a script cannot.
Take Back Your Hiring Process
We can take the hiring process back. Open the applications. Stop leaving postings up until 10,000 candidates have applied (yes, I have seen that). If you cannot find the right person in 100 applications, the problem usually is not the applicants. It is the job posting.Ā
The job market is already rough, and companies have the power to make it better. That starts with three commitments:Ā
- Stop posting fake jobs to collect resumes.Ā
- Stop recruiting for positions you have no intention of filling.Ā
- Stop ghosting. Let people know where they stand, even when the answer is no.Ā
I am not the only one noticing. HR Dive has reported on how common employer ghosting has become, and Talent Development magazine has covered the rise of fake job listings.Ā
What Ghosting Looks Like From the Candidate Side
Recently I applied for a job and received the standard message: thank you for applying, there are many candidates, please be patient while we review. Two hours later, an automated rejection arrived. A week after that, I received a second rejection from the same company.Ā
Same company, two rejections, and no explanation. A candidate reads that as a sign of how the rest of the process runs. Your hiring process is often a candidate’s first real look at how you treat people.Ā
Five Small Hiring Process Fixes You Can Make This Week
- Read the applications yourself. Even a real sample beats letting keywords decide who gets seen.Ā
- Put a real person in the first conversation, even if it is a short phone call.Ā
- Post roles you actually plan to fill, and take the posting down when you do.Ā
- Tell every applicant what to expect and when they will hear from you.Ā
- Close the loop. A short, kind no costs you almost nothing and protects your reputation.Ā
If your hiring process is built on the fly, you are not alone, especially in a small business without a dedicated HR person. The Starter HR Kit gives you a practical starting point for the HR side of hiring, so your next hire begins with a clear, fair process instead of a scramble.Ā
We Can Do Better
People need jobs, and businesses need good people. A hiring process that is honest, human, and responsive serves both. We need to do better, and the good news is that most of it is within your control.
Is your hiring process working for you or against you?
I don’t do one-size-fits-all. I’ll help you build a hiring process that fits your business and treats every candidate with respect.Ā
